ComedyNews and Reviews

Shane Gillis Breaks His Silence on Joe Rogan, Calls His SNL Monologue “A Solid C Minus”

Shane Gillis performing stand-up with a microphone
🏆 The Unseen Comics Awards 2026Nominate the comedians who deserve it. Nominations close November 30. Submit your nominations →

A month after his second turn hosting Saturday Night Live, Shane Gillis has spoken publicly about the backlash to his opening monologue. On 13 November he went on The Joe Rogan Experience, called the monologue “a solid C minus”, and said the reaction “obviously had a lot to do with the climate”.

The joke

Gillis hosted SNL on 10 October. In his monologue he told the audience he had not been to the gym in a long time, then said: “I didn’t know women just dress like wh*res now?”

Who criticised it

Former SNL host Dan Levy said he was “speechless that something like that can exist on live national television.” He added that women wearing short shorts to the gym does not make them what Gillis called them, and that it makes the men saying it misogynists.

SNL alum Ego Nwodim posted a gym mirror selfie captioned “wh*re reporting for duty.” Comedian Phoebe Robinson and former cast member Cecily Strong also criticised the joke, and some critics questioned why SNL boss Lorne Michaels let it air.

Who defended him

Others came to his defence. SNL alum Dana Carvey said he saw it as “a joke” and did not understand the controversy. Jimmy Carr said that “intent is much more important than content”, and that Gillis was trying to make people laugh.

The same monologue led to a callback on stage. Read Inde Navarrette Turned Shane Gillis’s SNL Gym Joke Into a Perfect Callback.

What Gillis said on Joe Rogan

On the question of why the show did not cut the line, Gillis said SNL does not sign off on a host’s stand-up in advance:

Not to defend SNL, they don’t approve it. I mean, they could shut it down.

Shane Gillis

He said that before the show he had warned the team the monologue was weak but harmless:

Fellas, I’m giving you a solid C minus of a monologue, but I promise there’s no controversy.

Shane Gillis

He said the size of the reaction “obviously had a lot to do with the climate” at the time, and added that, for the record, he does not have a problem with what women wear to the gym. He also said that this time he deleted all his social media straight away, unlike in 2019, when he kept his accounts and read what people were saying.

He joked that he could take critics off his tour dates, then said the idea had come from his agent and that he would not do it.

His second brush with SNL

This is not the first time SNL has put Gillis in the headlines. In 2019 he was announced as a new cast member, then let go days later after old clips of him using racial slurs resurfaced. He went on to host the show for the first time in 2024, and returned to host again this October.

Another comedian found himself in the news this month. Read Dave Chappelle Is in Hot Water Over a Charlie Kirk Joke at Madison Square Garden.

Featured photo: Shane Gillis by Quintin Soloviev, via Wikimedia Commons, licensed under CC BY 4.0. Cropped from the original.

Enjoyed this interview?

Hop For Pop is researched, recorded, edited and written by one person, and it’s free to read. If this one made you laugh or taught you something, you can buy us a coffee.

Buy us a coffee ☕ $5

Follow

Follow The Comics Unseen and Hop For Pop on Instagram for more comedy news.

Related posts
ComedyInterviews

André De Freitas Wanted to Be a Surfer. Nine Years Later, He Is a Comedy Cellar Regular

ComedyInterviews

Fabrizio Copano Built Chile’s Stand-Up Scene Above a Tango Club. Now He Earns Every Second at the Comedy Cellar

ComedyInterviews

Fábio Rabin’s Parents Joked They Would Sell Him. So He Helped Build Brazilian Stand-Up

ComedyNews and Reviews

5 Comedy Series Everyone Must Watch, If You Haven’t Yet

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Worth reading...
The Ultimate Comedy Quiz: Only True Stand-Up Fans Can Score 10/10